Lawyers Fined by Judge for Inventing Cases in Chat App

Date:

Two lawyers have been fined a joint total of $5,000 and ordered to reach out to judges featured in the fake cases generated by artificial intelligence (AI) tool, ChatGPT. This is the first time that major sanctions have been put in place for the use of AI in the legal field. New York-based law firm, Levidow Levidow & Oberman, P.C., expressed their intention to comply with the court’s order but they “respectfully disagree” that anyone at the firm “acted in bad faith.” In a statement to Forbes, the firm continued, “We made a good faith mistake in failing to believe that a piece of technology could be making up cases out of whole cloth.”

The lawyers in question, Michael Schwartz and Jillian Scheinfeld, had attempted to use six cases, which they believed to be genuine precedent cases, to support a lawsuit against Avianca Airlines. Schwartz went back to ChatGPT to provide fabricated legal documents after the authenticity of the case documents came under scrutiny from the opposing party. David Castel, the presiding judge, considered sanctions against the lawyers and threw out the lawsuit against Avianca Airlines, ruling that it was filed too late.

The use of AI in law has been a complex issue, and this is one of the first times that a case has been so heavily sanctioned due to misusing the technology. Schwartz admitted to using ChatGPT but claimed that he had no intention to deceive the court and acted in good faith. The court found that the cases provided did not exist and contained false judicial decisions, quotes and internal citations.

See also  AI Therapy: A New ChatGPT Use Case

As technology continues to evolve and affect various industries, it is important to maintain ethical and proper use of it. This case serves as a reminder that AI cannot be completely relied on to conduct legal procedures. Lawyers must maintain their responsibility to ensure they are using genuine research and evidence, or they could face serious consequences, as seen in this case.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) Related to the Above News

What happened to the lawyers who used an AI tool to invent cases?

The lawyers were fined a joint total of $5,000 and ordered to reach out to judges featured in the fake cases generated by the AI tool.

What is the name of the AI tool the lawyers used?

The AI tool the lawyers used is called ChatGPT.

Has this ever happened before?

This is one of the first times that a major sanction has been put in place for the use of AI in the legal field.

Did the law firm comply with the court's order?

Yes, the law firm expressed their intention to comply with the court's order.

Did the lawyers act in good faith?

The lawyers claimed that they acted in good faith but the court found that the cases provided did not exist and contained false judicial decisions, quotes, and internal citations.

What is the lesson learned from this case?

This case serves as a reminder that AI cannot be completely relied on to conduct legal procedures. Lawyers must maintain their responsibility to ensure they are using genuine research and evidence, or they could face serious consequences, as seen in this case.

Please note that the FAQs provided on this page are based on the news article published. While we strive to provide accurate and up-to-date information, it is always recommended to consult relevant authorities or professionals before making any decisions or taking action based on the FAQs or the news article.

Aniket Patel
Aniket Patel
Aniket is a skilled writer at ChatGPT Global News, contributing to the ChatGPT News category. With a passion for exploring the diverse applications of ChatGPT, Aniket brings informative and engaging content to our readers. His articles cover a wide range of topics, showcasing the versatility and impact of ChatGPT in various domains.

Share post:

Subscribe

Popular

More like this
Related

Snoop Dogg Joins Drake & Kendrick Lamar Feud with Hilarious AI Track

Snoop Dogg joins Drake & Kendrick Lamar feud with hilarious AI track. Drake releases Taylor Made Freestyle with Tupac & Snoop Dogg voices.

German Chancellor Urges Fair Trade with China Amid Economic Struggles

German Chancellor urges fair trade with China to address economic struggles. Visit results in progress on trade barriers. Strengthening ties between the two countries.

Elon Musk Takes OpenAI to Court Over For-Profit Shift

Elon Musk sues OpenAI over shift to for-profit model, sparking legal battle in the AI industry. Learn more about the clash here.

Truecaller Director Pragya Misra: From WhatsApp to OpenAI in India

Pragya Misra, the first employee of OpenAI in India, showcases her leadership in the tech industry from her previous roles at Truecaller and WhatsApp.